From my understanding even if a new provider did do what it takes for a point up, bbbj, dfk, greek, 2 guys, or really bi, they will still downgrade the score if the provider is new or the hobbyist is new, especially if they're both new.
So, if a credible member reviewed a new provider, they would probably let him score her whatever. Or, if a new guy reviews a provider who already has a lot of other reviews saying the same thing.
Basically, if you are new, in order to get on you gotta take a few lower scores even if you follow their guidelines. Dumb! The body of the review will contradict the low score, so they make no sense only going by numbers.